How the Yale Halloween Vigilantes Finally Got Their Way

Nicholas and Erika Christakis step down from their administrative posts, closing a sorry chapter at the university.
By
Zachary Young
June 3, 2016 6:18 p.m. ET
389 COMMENTS

Nicholas Christakis and his wife, Erika, came to Yale University in 2013 with high expectations. At Harvard, the couple had held prominent teaching and administrative roles. At Yale, Dr. Christakis, a sociologist and physician, received a laboratory directorship and four appointments; Ms. Christakis, an expert in early-childhood education, became a seminar instructor. Two years after their arrival at Yale, Dr. Christakis and Ms. Christakis were awarded positions as master and associate master of Silliman College, Yale’s largest residential college. (I attend the university and reside at Silliman).

Last week, the Christakises resigned those posts.

Early-childhood educator Erika Christakis.

Early-childhood educator Erika Christakis. Photo: Axel Dupeux/Wall Street Journal

Their departure comes as no surprise. For seven months, the couple has been subject to bullying, harassment and intimidation. They inadvertently became a national media story last fall and catalyzed a month of campus protests, prompting Yale President Peter Salovey to tell minority students: “We failed you.”

The Christakises encountered a witch-hunt mentality on a contemporary college campus. It began fittingly on the day before Halloween, when Ms. Christakis questioned guidelines from Yale’s Intercultural Affairs Committee warning against “culturally unaware or insensitive” costumes. Ms. Christakis reasoned, in an email to Silliman residents, that students should decide for themselves how to dress for Halloween, without the administration’s involvement.

Student radicals of the 1960s might have recognized her note as a defense of free expression, but those days are long gone. Instead, Ms. Christakis was denounced as a proponent of cultural insensitivity. Irate students circulated petitions, wrote editorials and posted social-media tirades. They scribbled criticisms in chalk outside the Christakises’ home and posted degrading images of them online. Two student groups demanded their removal from Silliman.

In one incident captured on video, dozens of students confronted Dr. Christakis, berating and cursing him, while a Yale dean looked on. One student screamed at Dr. Christakis: “You should not sleep at night. You are disgusting.” Yale College Dean Jonathan Holloway did not help matters when, the next day, he offered his “unambiguous” support for the Intercultural Affairs Committee’s guidelines, calling their intent “exactly right.”

Though President Salovey rejected calls for the Christakises’ firing, animus for the couple simmered. In December, a crate appeared outside their Silliman office containing a sombrero and a Rastafarian wig—the sort of Halloween paraphernalia now taboo on college campuses. In January, a fake email purporting to be from Ms. Christakis objected to the administration’s safety ban on hoverboard scooters. The couple canceled teaching plans for the spring.

At Silliman College’s graduation ceremony on May 23, several seniors refused to accept their diplomas from Dr. Christakis or to shake his hand. Two days later, the Christakises announced that they would step down from Silliman. Many students celebrated the news on Facebook.

While the Christakises remain affiliated with Yale and could return to teaching, their resignations from Silliman had the air of a chapter closing in one of the more disturbing episodes of modern campus intolerance.

The Christakises made remarkably unlikely targets for purging by student activists. The couple has a long record of advocating for minority students, and the Christakises have devoted much of their academic work to highlighting health and development problems facing underserved communities.

In the months since the controversy erupted, the Christakises have met one-on-one with offended students. They have invited their critics over for a group lunch to “continue the conversation.” Though not always with success, the Christakises tried to improve a fraught situation, with little backup from the administration.

“We have great respect for every member of our community, friend and critic alike,” Dr. Christakis wrote in announcing the couple’s resignation from Silliman, effective in July. “We remain hopeful that students at Yale can express themselves and engage complex ideas within an intellectually plural community.”

On the evidence of the past year or so across American campuses, such hope is becoming ever more beleaguered. With luck, the sorry episode at Yale will cause students to spend less time vilifying professors and more time engaging with their ideas.

Mr. Young, a Robert L. Bartley Fellow at the Journal this summer, will be a senior at Yale University in the fall.

In Memoriam

Please scroll down.  This page will be updated shortly
Kenneth Parker Abbe, Jr.

10-Nov-66

Robert Thompson Achor

26-Jan-04

Lincoln Ames

22-Feb-06

Harvey Adolphus Andruss,Jr 14-Jul-11
Samuel Nathaniel Antupit

5-Apr-03

William Emmons Aull

4-24-09

Neils Breinholt Bach, Jr.

18-Sep-09

Kenneth Raybourne Bailey

30-Dec-65

Peter Anthony Banker

8-Apr-96

Frederick George Bannerot, III

14-Apr-05

Robert Allen Barbee 12-May-12
Walter Eugene Barnett

25-Mar-85

Robert King Barton 6-Apr-66
Robert Thomas Beggs 8-Nov-55
Harry Bryner Benninghoff 3-Mar-10
Lawrence Chamberlain Bentley

1-Jul-87

Nicholas John Benza

28-Dec-95

Walter Harold Bergler, Jr.

28-Apr-00

David Berliner

1-Apr-91

William DeForest Bertini, Jr.

19-Aug-62

Kenneth Fletcher Bick 19-2-13
Royal Gardner Bivins, Jr.

15-Aug-92

David Chancellor Black

24-Dec-07

William Wightman Blair, 3rd

19-Aug-03

John Gerald Blakesley Apr-11
Paul Gregory Boornazian

27-Jan-82

Robert Knapp Boyle

24-Dec-81

John Howell Brainard Aug-12
Henry Morton Brinckerhoff III

3-Oct-93

Benjamin Temple Brown, Jr.

24-Aug-07

James Crosby Brown, Jr.

10-Jul-90

John Welburn Brown, Jr.

2-Jul-58

Waldo Hayward Brown

30-Jul-87

Robert Gary Bulkley

23-Oct-98

Robert Ernest Burgett

16-Oct-65

John Kemper Cannon 15-Dec-02
Francis Peter Capra

6-Feb-02

James Campbell. Carey, Jr.

8-May-02

Sten Helge Carlson

23-Mar-00

David Duncan Carrington

24-Jul-84

David Cassard

21-Jan-85

Robert Clayton Casto

5-Apr-98

Dwight Lewis Chamberlain

5-Mar-92

Thomas Sabin Chase

11-Jun-56

George Chranewycz

29-Dec-96

Bruce Linden Christy

21-Sep-86

Frederick Waldo Clapp

24-Jan-87

David Lang Clark Feb-12
John Phelps Clark

2-Feb-08

John Paul Cleary

1-Feb-09

Richard Joseph Coburn

23-Dec-08

Charles Seymour Cohen

16-Feb-04

Charles Parrish Coleman

1-Nov-74

Thomas Charles Coleman

14-Sep-94

Charles Louis Combe

7-Nov-70

William Coast Conkling

3-27

Chandler Bullock Converse

1-Jul-97

Donald Glenn Corbett, Jr.

28-Mar-64

Joseph Edward Corn, Jr.

16-Oct-97

Thomas Hillary Maher Cornell Mar-11
Gibbons Gray Cornwell III 3-Feb-13
Edmonson Shorter Couric, Jr.

7-Feb-92

Harris Livermore Coulter

28-Oct-09

Artemas Holmes Crimmins, Jr.

14-Jan-98

Charles Edward Crowley, Jr. 24-Apr-12
Richmond Hodges Curtiss, Jr.

4-Aug-04

Theodorus Van Wyck Cushny

29-Dec-06

Roger Morgan Daily

20-Apr-80

James Dwight Dana

9-Aug-07

Sturgis Williams Darling, Jr.

30-June-09

Walter Ferguson Dater, Jr.

14-Jan-74

John Randolph Davis

30-Apr-95

John Robert Davy

Mar-10

Peter Lindsay Dawson

28-Jul-04

Franklin John Demcak

22-Apr-91

Sherman Hambleton Deveas, Jr.

21-Jan-94

Paul Cameron Devore 25-Oct-08
Chauncey Foulke Dewey Feb-02
John Davis Dibble 2-Dec-09
James Edward Donnellan, Jr. 26-Nov-05
Francis Thomas Driscoll

3-Oct-87

Charles Eugene Drummey 7-Apr-13
Harold Harlan Earnhart

10-May-97

Herbert Clarence Edgar, Jr.

30-Jan-90

David Sterritt Ellis

14-Apr-57

James Louis Ellis

17-Apr-96

William Homer Ellis, Jr.

10-Nov-94

George Pomeroy Eustis

7-Sep-78

Roger Clinton Evans

4-Oct-03

Tilghman Boyd Evans

8-Jan-07

Wallace Washburn Everett III

7-Feb-97

David Bruce Falconer

13-Dec-84

Frederick Bartlett Farwell

26-Apr-79

Charles John Faulstich

5-May-80

Vance Brown Field

19-Apr-07

Allan David Foster Mar-12
Conrad Cecil Fowkes, Jr.

Dec-09

Ronald James Fracasse

17-Feb-07

Jerome Edward Frankel

6-Aug-06

John LIonel  Devon Frazier

26-Dec-03

Hovey Thomas Freeman, Jr.

29-Nov-79

Morris Morton Freilich

24-Sep-67

Albert Carl Frost III

Feb-09

G. Robert Gage

30-Aug-05

John Currier Gallagher

22-Jul-88

Harry Augustus Garfield II

18-Aug-96

Peter Edward Geis

4-Dec-01

Daniel George Gibbens 4-Jan-11
Richard Cammann Gifford

23-May-95

Robert Paul Gillete

20-Jul-05

Russel Hart Goddard

16-Jan-07

Eric John Macaulay Godfrey

Mar-10

Barry Campbell Good

22-Oct-88

Arthur Landis Goodreds

23-Apr-81

William Albert Goering

8-Jun-05

Arnld Earl Green

3-Dec-04

Peter Anthony Greeman

22-Oct-07

Benson Suydam Greene

11-Oct-04

Paul Cooksey Grider, Jr.

13-Aug-99

Rrichard Seaton Grimm 11
Richard Louis Grosse

13-Jun-08

Frederick Thomas Guckenberger

6-Mar-98

Henry Gund, III

26-Oct-94

Alan Montgomery Gunn

Apr-56

Richard Arthur Hadley

26-Dec-90

John Tardy Haesler

20-Mar-61

Morgan Hovey Harris, Jr.

8-Dec-92

James Pinckney Harrison, Jr.

May-10

Oliver Hazzard

22-Feb-09

Francis Edward Healy Jr.

13-Dec-99

Thomas Williams Heenan

2-May-06

John Harrison Heidt

Oct-09

Bradley Trowbridge Hemingway

19-Oct-92

Robert Lee Hess

12-Jan-92

Henry Morrison Hille

4-Oct-02

Alfred Donald Hilse

13-Dec-78

Richard C. Hodges

Aug-04

Robert Carr Hodgkins

22-Dec-03

Bernard Hoffmann

4-18-09

Marsh Hanford Holt

10-Mar-97

John Hobart Hoskins

2-Aug-89

Charlton Alexander Howard

15-Jan-00

Richard Harper Howarth Dec-12
Richard Heasley Hughes

7-Jul-04

David Andrew Hunter, Jr.

1-Apr-93

John William Hunter, Jr.

Jul-87

William Stoddard Hutchins

8-Mar-95

William Merrill Hutchinson

4-Apr-08

Irwin Jerome Hyman

25-Dec-95

William Malcolm Jacobs

1-Apr-79

Lewis Paul James, Jr. 25-Dec-12
Jay Janis

26-Oct-92

Robert Neal Johnson

Dec-08

Elmer William Johnson, Jr.

19-Feb-08

Paul Edward Jones, Jr.

4-Jun-06

Arnold Kaiman

31-Dec-07

Robert Hine Kelly

14-Jan-76

Walter Charles Kilrea

28-Sep-87

Frank Joseph Kinney, Jr.

28-Sep-86

Jay Ward Kislak

Oct-10

Werner Albert Klee

2-Apr-04

Frederick Henry Knight III

May-10

John Garrett Kolakowski

8-Feb-94

Robert Albert Krantz, Jr.

18-Dec-04

Bryant Alexander Langmuir, Jr.

28-Nov-00

Albert EEffingham Lawrence, 2d

30-Aug-94

Alan T. Le Win

11-Aug-95

Roger Lee

7-Nov-01

Arnold Thomas Lipman 13-May-04
Robert Louis Livingston

27-May-79

 

Alfred T. Loeffler, Jr.

26-Oct-03

Peter Selmer Loft

14-Feb-83

Myron Lotz

11-Jul-99

William Pierce Loving Oct-12
Robert Farleigh MacKay 18-Nov-11
Harold Orlando MacLean, Jr.

Nov-84

Lawrence Scott Maguire

8-Jul-96

Henry Allen Mali

5-Jul-90

Elliot Meyer Marcus 25-Jul-11
Mason Martens

7-Feb-91

Chamberlin McAllester 27-Oct-11
William Rockefeller McAlpin, Jr.

25-Feb-70

John Starkey McCarthy

19-Jun-74

Robert Clifton McCollough

4-Aug-06

Patrick M. McGrady, Jr.

12-Dec-03

Robert Angus McKenzie

6-Dec-02

William Huston McKim

10-Apr-54

James Ward McKinster 24-Jul-12
Frank Boyd McKown, Jr.

10-Jul-04

Peter Brewer McLaughlin

3-Mar-78

Robert Thompson McWade, Jr.

12-Dec-64

Robert Hartley Mead

26-Apr-98

Robert Frank Meditz

14-Dec-56

Richard William Mellon

28-Sep-85

Robert David Mercer -13
Robert Graff Merrick, Jr.

5-Sep-90

Frank Rogerson Meyer

4-25-09

Harry Alvin Miskimin, Jr.

24-Oct-95

John Galvin Mitchell

7-Jul-07

William Wise Mitchell, Jr.

1-Feb-93

Robert Brownell Moon

17-Oct-95

Thurston Maxwell Moore

31-Dec-85

Edward Glancy Moran, Jr.

1-Dec-96

Charles LeBaron Morse

26-Jan-78

Lee Moulton

24-Dec-91

Charles Neave

24-Sep-05

Richard Gregg Neville

5-Oct-71

John Newman

21-Mar-11

Edward Michael O”Brien

20-Jan-04

Francis. James O’Brien

29-May-98

Jose Maria Obando

1970

William Philip Offenbacher

17-Oct-89

Robert Ford Ordway

21-Aug-53

Herman Osterhus

19-Sep-07

Juris Padegs

Dec-09

Bernard Berenger Pelly, Jr. Nov-11
Edward Leslie Pendargast, Jr. 17-Sep-02
William Richard Petricone

3-Aug-01

Charles Alan Phillips

18-Jun-94

William Lewis Phillips Jr.

3-May-97

Ralph Wesley Piersall, Jr.

25-Jan-74

Dixon Sanford Pike

29-Jun-01

Arnold G. Plumley 28-May-99
James Lee Poindexter

15-Sep-02

Robert Keyes Poole

12-May-78

Peter Nolasco Prior

26-Mar-07

Alfred Irving Puchner

13-Aug-02

William John Rague 11-Apr-13
James Annan Ralston

8-Jul-96

Roger Duffey Redden

31-Jan-08

William Reedy

24-Oct-08

Robert Gordon Reponen

6-Nov-82

Kenneth Gray Reynolds

12-May-96

John Wilbur Ricketts

25-Aug-98

Rodney Carter Reynolds

12-Oct-65

Gaius Barrett Rich IV 11-Jan-13
Larry Marvin Riggs

15-Jun-08

James Ver Plank Ritchey III

14-Jun-69

Roger Clifton Robbins

16-Apr-69

Lathrop Ellicott Roberts

3-Jul-83

Lewis Reed Robinson

14-Dec-98

Donald Wilson Robotham 7-Apr-13
Thomas Scott Robson

22-Oct-70

John Evans Rose, Jr 20-July-12
Robert Selden Rose, Jr.

22-Dec-83

Albert Miller Ross

21-Sp-05

Donald Peabody Ross, Jr.

30-Jun-00

Walter Lind Ross II

8-Aug-90

Curtis Witbeck Rowley

22-May-87

Frank Carpenter Royer, Jr.

11-May-96

James Elvin Rumsey

13-Feb-79

Sigurd Carl Sandzen, Jr. 11-July-12
Henry Wilcox Schaefer

17-Oct-85

Stanley Wolfgang Schroeder

18-Mar-87

Robert James Schultz

Apr-05

Jack Dale Scott

8-Apr-85

Lewis Jeffrey Selznick

12-May-97

Wm. Greenough Thayer Shedd, Jr.

14-Aug-85

Russell Smith Shelton

29-Jun-96

Roger Sherman

20-Sep-00

Dawson Shoemaker

18-July-09

Howard William Shoemaker 01-Apr-12
George Austin Shutt 19-Jan-13
George Charles Sinclair, Jr.

5-Aug-93

Ronald Max Sindberg

28-Apr-98

Preston Sinks

16-Jun-05

Charles Arthur Slanetz, Jr.

12-Jun-06

Jesse Roland Smith, Jr.

Dec-10

Roger Haskell Smith

12-Jul-80

Rutger Morse Smith

2-Oct-81

William Snyder

23-Jan-02

Peter Beaufort Spender

22-Aug-98

Theodore Anastasios Stamas

3-Sep-04

Joe Clayton Stephenson

24-Apr-11

Douglas Stevens

Oct-10

Dwight Lathrop Stocker, Jr.

18-Jan-70

Donald Stuart Stoll

15-Jun-59

Edward Durrell Stone, Jr

2-July-09

Robert Gilbert Stone

4-Mar-04

William Edward Stout

4-Feb-92

Daniel Robert Sweedler

16-Mar-74

Edmund Kearsky Swigart

14-May-09

Richard Joseph Sylvester

16-Dec-06

John Perry Talbot 18-Dec-02
Armen Haig Tashjian July-2-09
Frank Emery Taylor

25-May-71

Charles Dean Temple

10-Apr-54

Bruce Thorne, Jr.

28-Mar-78

Edward Joseph Toohey

30-Sep-09

Charles William Toti

29-Aug-00

Ralph Tucker, Jr.

19-Aug-90

Bruce Valentine

5-Feb-09

Walter Varenka

29-Dec-90

Andrew Neal Vladimir

15-Dec-08

Harry Charles Volrath III

14-Apr-68

Marshall Waddell

13-Jul-95

Rodney Belknap Wagner

24-Mar-05

William Durrie Waldron, Jr.

7-Oct-01

Lawrence Richard Walken

28-Dec-01

Malcolm Wallop 14-Sep-11
Joseph Michael Walsh, Jr.

21-Sep-98

Jay Ward

Jun-10

Dennis Charles Kelliher Warner

17-Apr-04

John Dustin Waters Waterman

25-Feb-95

Harrison Thornton Watson, Jr. 12-Dec-02
Edwin Snell Weaver Dec-10
Douglas West

27-Nov-95

John Wallace White

15-Jun-03

Roger Quincy White

10-Oct-08

 Martin Taylor Whitmer 13-Aug-11
Albert Aarthur Tilney Wickersham

4-Jun-90

Edward Bartlett Wicks III

1-Jun-98

Daniel Ewing Wight, Jr.

23-Feb-94

James Jerome Wilhelm 13-Dec-12
Howard Hunter Williams III 21-July-12
Thomas Ormiston Williams

4-Dec-05

William Jay Willis 1-Nov-12
Henry J. Winkler

30-Mar-09

Jay Joseph Winokur

Jul-10

Burnside Winslow, Jr.

19-Dec-99

Thomas Crawford Witherspoon, Jr.

20-Jan-10

Winfield Scott Witherwax, Jr.

6-Jun-63

Thomas Edward Woodward 31-Oct-11
David Thorpe Workman

26-Sep-97

William Wrigley

8-Mar-99

Douglas Clinton Wynn

7-Sep-01

Samuel McClay Yonce Sep-12
Thomas Harold York

28-Jun-94

Benjamin Phillip Uroff

17-Oct-05

Peter R. Veit

16-Feb-07