Several campus names are more objectionable than John C. Calhoun—including Elihu Yale.

Yale University announced Saturday that it would change the name of Calhoun College, one of its original 12 residential colleges that opened in the early 1930s. Henceforth, the college will be named in honor of Grace Hopper, an early computer scientist and naval officer.
No sentient observer of the American academic scene could have been surprised by the move to ditch John C. Calhoun, the 19th-century South Carolina statesman after whom the college was originally named. On the contrary, the unspoken response was “What took them so long?”
Since last August, when Yale’s president, Peter Salovey, announced that he was convening a Committee to Establish Principles for Renaming—yes, really—the handwriting had been on the wall for Calhoun, a distinguished Yale alumnus who served as a congressman, senator, secretary of war, secretary of state and vice president.
Like Belshazzar before him, Calhoun had been weighed and found wanting. He may have been a brilliant orator and a fierce opponent of encroaching federal power, but he was also a slave holder. And unlike many of his peers, Calhoun argued that slavery was not merely a necessary evil but a “positive good,” because it provided for slaves better than they could provide for themselves.
You might, like me, think that Calhoun was wrong about that. But if you are Peter Salovey, you have to disparage Calhoun as a “white supremacist” whose legacy—“racism and bigotry,” according to a university statement—was fundamentally “at odds” with the noble aspirations of Yale University (“improving the world today and for future generations . . . through the free exchange of ideas in an ethical, interdependent, and diverse community”).
During a conference-call press briefing Saturday, and throughout the documents related to the Calhoun decision, officials have been careful to stress that the university operates with a “strong presumption against” renaming things. Because they do not seek to “erase history,” the officials insist, renaming things for ideological reasons would be “exceptionally rare.”
When you study the four principles Mr. Salovey’s committee came up with to justify a renaming, you can see why it took so long. The task, it seems clear, was to find a way to wipe away Calhoun College while simultaneously immunizing other institutions at Yale from politicized rebaptism.
Did the principal legacy of the honored person “fundamentally conflict” with the university’s mission? Was that legacy “contested” within the person’s lifetime? Were the reasons that the university honored him at odds with Yale’s mission? Does the named building or program play a substantial role in “forming community at Yale”?
Readers who savor tortuous verbal legerdemain will want to acquaint themselves with the “Letter of the Advisory Group on the Renaming of Calhoun College,” which is available online. It is a masterpiece of the genre.
Is it also convincing? I think the best way to answer that is to fill out the historical picture a bit. Nearly every Yale official who spoke at Saturday’s press briefing had to describe John Calhoun (1782-1850) as a “white supremacist.” Question: Who among whites at the time was not? Take your time.
Calhoun owned slaves. But so did Timothy Dwight, Calhoun’s mentor at Yale, who has a college named in his honor. So did Benjamin Silliman, who also gives his name to a residential college, and whose mother was the largest slave owner in Fairfield County, Conn. So did Ezra Stiles,John Davenport and even Jonathan Edwards, all of whom have colleges named in their honor at Yale.
Writing in these pages last summer, I suggested that Yale table the question of John Calhoun and tackle some figures even more obnoxious to contemporary sensitivities. One example was Elihu Yale, the American-born British merchant who, as an administrator in India, was an active participant in the slave trade.
President Salovey’s letter announcing that Calhoun College would be renamed argues that “unlike . . . Elihu Yale, who made a gift that supported the founding of our university . . . Calhoun has no similarly strong association with our campus.” What can that mean? Calhoun graduated valedictorian from Yale College in 1804. Is that not a “strong association”? (Grace Hopper held two advanced degrees from the university but had no association with the undergraduate Yale College.)
As far as I have been able to determine, Elihu Yale never set foot in New Haven. His benefaction of some books and goods worth £800 helped found Yale College, not Yale University. And whereas the 11th edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica praises Calhoun for his “just and kind” treatment of slaves and the “stainless integrity” of his character, Elihu Yale had slaves flogged, hanged a stable boy for stealing a horse, and was eventually removed from his post in India for corruption. Is all that not “fundamentally at odds” with the mission of Peter Salovey’s Yale?
Mr. Salovey stepped out of a board meeting briefly to join the conference call on Saturday. More in sadness than in anger he disparaged John Calhoun, praised Grace Hopper, and affirmed his commitment to diversity, free inquiry, etc. Then one of the reporters asked why he was renaming Calhoun College for a white woman, especially since February was Black History Month. Oh dear. Thanks so much, must get back to that board meeting now.
In “The Crack-Up,” F. Scott Fitzgerald comments that “the test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function.” First-rate or not, the evolving politically correct circus at Yale does not offer a lot of support for that proposition.
Mr. Kimball is editor and publisher of the New Criterion and president and publisher of Encounter Books.
Nicely put, Cheers!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
buying viagra prescription
buy viagra online
generic viagra baku az rx-health
generic viagra 100mg
Nicely put, Regards!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
cvs viagra
viagra for sale uk
buy viagra porno at maygreat org
viagra without a doctor prescription
Thank you. An abundance of facts!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra in manchester uk
viagra without a doctors prescription
arlene farmer viagra
viagra pills
Amazing tons of great information!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
discount viagra and cialis
viagra for women
what is better viagra or cialis
viagra for women
Nicely put. Regards!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
find search viagra edinburgh computer sites
generic viagra 100mg
taking viagra and l caradine
viagra for women
You have made your point quite effectively!.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra cialis levitra reviews
viagra without a doctors prescription
what does viagra actually do
viagra for women
Awesome forum posts. With thanks!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
russian band viagra nude
cheap viagra
viagra without prescription uk pharmacy
viagra for women
You actually stated this exceptionally well!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra edinburgh search find pages sites
buy generic viagra
viva viagra commercials
generic viagra 100mg
Thanks a lot. Wonderful stuff!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
funkadelic viagra
generic viagra online
recreational use of viagra
viagra generic
Truly a good deal of amazing information.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra price at costco pharmacy
buy generic viagra
viagra fedex overnight shipping
viagra generic
Good posts. Thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
how old to take viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
i took two viagra
viagra 100mg
Thank you. Wonderful information.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
rx viagra toledo
buy viagra online
womens viagra on the doctors
buy viagra
Many thanks, I appreciate this.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
when will viagra become generic
buy generic viagra
discrete viagra australia
cheap viagra
Really plenty of helpful tips.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra adverse events
generic viagra
edinburgh uk viagra search cialis charles
viagra without a doctor prescription
Whoa all kinds of very good information.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
newsletter viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
mexico and viagra and price
viagra pills
Incredible a good deal of good information.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
buy viagra proffesional
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra cupons
generic viagra
Wow quite a lot of helpful info!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
levitra viagra vs
generic viagra 100mg
generic levitra celias viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
Amazing all kinds of good knowledge.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
tolerance for viagra
buy generic viagra
2cialis levitra viagra vs vs
viagra without a doctors prescription
Regards, I appreciate it!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
glucophage viagra
generic viagra online
how to buy viagra cheap
viagra pills
Thanks a lot. I appreciate this!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra joke
viagra generic
save on viagra
generic viagra
Wonderful stuff, Kudos!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
paxil viagra
viagra for sale uk
pokemon gold buy viagra
generic viagra 100mg
Awesome content, Many thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra quicker
viagra pills
female infertility and viagra
buy viagra online
You suggested that fantastically!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
discount generic viagra soft tabs
viagra without a doctor prescription
high off viagra
viagra for women
Regards! I like this!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
watermelon rine viagra
buy viagra online
tiesto viagra
buy viagra online
Really quite a lot of great knowledge.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
female viagra without a prescription
viagra pills
viagra trial
viagra without a doctor prescription
Tips nicely taken!.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra levitra cialis which is free
viagra generic
viagra u s pharmacies
generic viagra 100mg
Thanks a lot. I like this.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
texas flomax interaction viagra
buy generic viagra
generic viagra pills from india
generic viagra 100mg
Whoa quite a lot of fantastic material.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra and india
generic viagra
m585 viagra
viagra for sale uk
You actually explained this exceptionally well.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
south beach diet buy viagra
buy viagra online
viagra online doma
viagra pills
Regards! Loads of advice!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
premium generic viagra
viagra pills
viagra and vioxx
buy generic viagra
Thank you! Ample posts.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
begining viagra dose
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra australia information
viagra for women
Nicely put, Cheers.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra dosage effects
viagra 100mg
buy viagra online a href
viagra without a doctors prescription
Thanks a lot. I enjoy this!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
stories from women that take viagra
viagra for women
5 citrate generic sildenafil viagra
viagra for women
Awesome info. Kudos.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
clearchannel radio and viagra founder
generic viagra 100mg
can you take viagra and levitra
generic viagra 100mg
Really all kinds of awesome knowledge.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra and cialis cheap
viagra pills
pharmacy ecstasy viagra
buy generic viagra
You explained it fantastically!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
is cialis as good as viagra
buy generic viagra
extend or viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
You said that exceptionally well.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra ill effects
cheap viagra
viagra reliabel testimonial
generic viagra
Wow a good deal of excellent data.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
cheap herbal viagra
generic viagra
viagra pharmacokinetics
viagra without a doctors prescription
Excellent posts. Regards!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
how long fo viagra to work
viagra for sale uk
pic viagra woman
viagra without a doctors prescription
Nicely spoken certainly! .
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra use side-effect long-term study
viagra 100mg
viagra canadian prescriptions
cheap viagra
Nicely spoken without a doubt. !
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
generic generic viagra tadalafil
cheap viagra
viagra trial size
viagra 100mg
Nicely put. Thanks a lot!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra jokes jokes
viagra for sale uk
buy viagra com
generic viagra 100mg
Regards, A good amount of forum posts!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
side effect of viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
watermelon viagra effects
viagra 100mg
Very good material. Thanks!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
clarisa nora doctorovich viagra
viagra for women
do you need prescription for viagra
generic viagra 100mg
Wow many of valuable advice.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
2003 cialis levitra market sales viagra
viagra for women
homopathic viagra
viagra generic
Helpful stuff. Appreciate it!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra after a tia
generic viagra 100mg
generic viagra blue pill 25mg
viagra 100mg
Kudos, Wonderful information!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
is viagra harmful to women
viagra without a doctors prescription
sublingual viagra preparation
viagra without a doctors prescription
You mentioned this wonderfully.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
natural viagra for woman
cheap viagra
viagra vending laws u k
viagra for women
Nicely put, Many thanks.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra penis pics
viagra for women
viagra vs nasal spray
viagra generic
Nicely put, Kudos.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
cheapest 100mg viagra delivered overnight
generic viagra
viagra and celias
viagra for sale uk
Nicely put. Thanks a lot!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
grneric viagra india
viagra without a doctor prescription
jelq on viagra
viagra online
You actually stated it perfectly!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra on sale in france
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra old effects of pill
buy viagra online
Amazing stuff, Thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra effective for females
viagra without a doctors prescription
what is viagra for women called
viagra for women
Wow many of beneficial information.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
viagra australia online
buy viagra
contraindications of viagra and coumadin
viagra generic
Kudos! Lots of info!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra paperweight closeout
buy generic viagra
viagra meloxicam interaction
viagra pills
Valuable forum posts. Thanks.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra find edinburgh pages search sites
generic viagra
viagra freebies
generic viagra 100mg
Cheers! Ample forum posts!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra online from canada
viagra for sale uk
edinburgh viagra find pages sites search
viagra for women
You said it very well..
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
kid wins teddybear with viagra shirt
cheap viagra
who is viagra target market
viagra generic
Appreciate it! Loads of tips!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra in mexico
buy viagra
maryland cialis tadalafil viagra
buy viagra online
Thanks. I like this.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
viagra drug name
generic viagra 100mg
hard erections without viagra
buy viagra online
With thanks. A good amount of posts!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra salute
buy viagra online
active compound viagra
viagra pills
You expressed that wonderfully!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
long term effects viagra cialis
generic viagra 100mg
eating watermelon works like viagra
buy generic viagra
Many thanks! Wonderful stuff!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
female viagra squirts
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra and and stimulant drugs
cheap viagra
You expressed it wonderfully.
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
best buy meridia phentermine propecia viagra
generic viagra
will viagra improve ed over time
viagra for sale uk
Cheers. Useful information!
http://viagrapego.com/
watermelon rhine natural viagra
generic viagra 100mg
penis sensitivity viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
Wonderful forum posts. Regards.
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
levitra viagra cialis best
viagra for sale uk
drm viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
Thank you! Lots of write ups!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
viagra drug zenegra
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra pregnancy fetus
buy viagra online
Amazing stuff. Thanks a lot.
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
long term side effects of viagra
viagra pills
generic viagra no prescriptio
viagra for sale uk
Many thanks, Quite a lot of write ups!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
order viagra visit your doctor online
viagra without a doctor prescription
four hour hard on viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
Appreciate it. Plenty of data!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
list generic viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra doctor torrance california
buy viagra
Thanks. Terrific information!
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
martin hickman and viagra
generic viagra online
something that works faster than viagra
cheap viagra
Appreciate it. Plenty of write ups!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
viagra etc
generic viagra
drug facts on women taking viagra
generic viagra 100mg